Quick answers
- A buyer's lender can require repairs before closing, even when the house is sold as-is.
- FHA and VA loans have their own minimum property standards. On an older house, peeling paint, a worn-out roof, unsafe wiring and utilities that are switched off are the items to watch.
- A credit generally can't replace a repair the lender requires. The lender wants the work done.
- If the appraisal comes in below the price, there are several ways to keep the sale together.
What the appraiser is looking at
Every appraiser estimates market value from recent comparable sales and the house's condition. On an inherited house, condition is where the questions come from. A house that hasn't been updated in decades can still appraise well if it's sound and safe. It's the safety and soundness items that turn into lender conditions.
FHA, VA and conventional loans
| Loan type | What can get flagged on an older house | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| FHA | Chipping or peeling paint on a house built before 1978; a roof with less than two years of life left; utilities not on at the appraisal; exposed or hazardous wiring; anything unsafe | The appraisal can call for repairs, an inspection by a specialist such as a roofer, or a return visit once the utilities are on. The buyer's lender decides what must be done before the loan funds. |
| VA | VA has its own minimum property requirements | Ask the buyer's lender early which ones apply to this house. |
| Conventional | Minor wear and dated finishes can be appraised "as is." Problems affecting safety, soundness or structure, and houses in the poorest condition rating, are appraised "subject to" repairs | Fewer required repairs, but serious problems, such as active leaks, a failing roof or structural damage, still become conditions. |
The standards exist so the house securing the loan is livable. They catch heirs off guard because nobody was living there to notice the peeling eaves or the dead furnace.
Who pays for lender-required repairs
That's negotiable. It can be settled in a few ways:
- The estate or trust does the work before closing, which can be the simplest choice for small items such as paint touch-ups and alarms.
- The estate lowers the price, and the work is still done before closing with the buyer's agreement.
- The buyer pays for the work, which still has to be done before the loan funds.
A credit generally can't replace a repair the lender requires, because the condition is about the house, not the money. Ask the buyer's lender early what will be required, so the work fits inside escrow. After the work, the lender needs acceptable proof it was completed, which may mean the appraiser coming back, and that adds a step before funding.
A before-you-list checklist for financed buyers
These items can be handled before the house is on the market, when there's no escrow deadline:
- Keep the electricity, water and any gas service on, and make sure the furnace and water heater work.
- On a house built before 1978, have any chipping or peeling paint corrected, inside and out. Federal rules require a lead-safe certified contractor for most paid work that disturbs that paint.
- Have an old roof looked at, and get a written bid if it needs work.
- Fix exposed wiring, missing outlet covers and anything else obviously unsafe.
- Make sure the smoke and carbon monoxide alarms work and the water heater is braced. California requires the bracing, and carbon monoxide alarms in homes with a heater or appliance that burns gas or another fossil fuel, a fireplace or an attached garage.
- Order the termite report and decide what to do about Section 1 items.
- Make the attic and crawlspace reachable, so the appraiser and inspector don't have to write "no access."
Pre-Listing Inspection for an Inherited San Diego House can find these at once and show which are worth doing.
When the appraisal comes in low
A low appraisal doesn't have to end the sale. The buyer's loan is based on the lower of the price and the appraised value, so the gap has to be closed somehow:
- The buyer's lender can submit a reconsideration of value, with comparable sales the appraiser may have missed.
- The estate lowers the price partway, and the buyer brings more cash for the rest.
- The buyer covers the whole gap in cash, which some contracts plan for with an appraisal gap clause.
- The estate lowers the price to the appraised value, when the value is right and the price was a stretch.
- The estate returns to the market, when the buyer can't or won't close the gap and there's time.
VA's Tidewater process gives the parties a chance to send the appraiser more comparable sales before a low value is final. Low VA Appraisal in San Diego: Tidewater and Your Offer explains it.
Pricing with the appraisal in mind from the start lowers the chance of a gap. When I price an inherited house, I read it the way the buyer's appraiser will, so the price holds up against both the comparable sales and the condition.
If the house is in probate or a trust
A buyer with a loan can buy a probate or trust house. The timeline just has to leave room for the appraisal, any lender repairs and the confirmation of the work, along with the estate's own steps. In a sale that needs court confirmation, a financed buyer also has to be ready to close on the court's schedule.
Comparing Offers on a San Diego Probate Home explains how to weigh a financed offer against a cash offer, and Buying a San Diego Probate Home With a Mortgage shows the same process from the buyer's side.
Questions heirs ask
We're selling as-is. Can the buyer's lender still make us fix things?
The lender can't make the estate do anything, but it can refuse to fund until certain repairs are done. As-is means the estate isn't promising repairs. It doesn't change the lender's standards. Small lender-required repairs can be worth making rather than losing a good buyer.
Can we give the buyer a credit instead of making the repair?
Generally not for repairs the lender requires, because the lender wants the condition fixed before it funds. Credits can work for items the lender doesn't require.
Do the utilities really need to be on for the appraisal?
They should be. Appraisers and inspectors need them to check the systems. If they're off for an FHA appraisal, the appraiser can make it subject to a return visit once they're restored, which can delay closing.
Should we only accept cash offers to avoid all this?
Not necessarily. A buyer with a loan may pay more, and some lender conditions cost little to fix ahead of time. Prepare the house, then compare offers by what each would leave the estate. Cash Offer or Listing? A Net-Proceeds Worksheet shows how.
Next step
Send me the address and what you know about the house's condition, and I'll tell you what a buyer's appraiser is likely to flag and what's worth fixing before you list. Call or text (619) 366-2000, or use the contact form.