Skip to content

San Diego Real Estate Guidance

Cash Offer or Listing? A Net-Proceeds Worksheet for an Inherited San Diego House

Published · Updated

Once a probate case is filed, the letters can start arriving: "We buy houses in any condition." "No repairs, no fees, no commissions." Probate filings are public, and some companies that buy houses for cash watch them. For a family that is grieving, and maybe living in another state, a number with no work attached can sound like relief.

Sometimes the cash offer is the better choice, and sometimes listing leaves the family much more. You can't tell by comparing an offer price with a listing price, because each comes with different deductions. This page gives you one worksheet for both, two worked examples that come out in opposite directions, and a way to find the listing price at which the two are even.

For the broader pros and cons, see Sell an Inherited House for Cash or List It?

Quick answers

  • Compare what each path leaves after its costs, not the two prices.
  • Start both columns on the same day, and count each cost once.
  • With a mortgage or reverse mortgage, use the payoff for each closing date, plus any loan payments the estate makes before that closing.
  • Neither path wins every time. The result turns on how far the cash offer sits below a supported market price, and on the extra costs and time listing adds.
  • In a probate sale that needs court confirmation, the price must be at least 90% of the probate referee's appraisal, and other buyers can overbid at the hearing.

Where a cash company's number comes from

Companies that buy houses to renovate and resell generally work backward from what the house should sell for after the work, subtracting repairs, their costs and their profit. One rule of thumb in that business is the "70% rule": pay no more than 70% of the after-repair value, minus repairs. On a hypothetical house worth $900,000 after $60,000 of work, that comes to $570,000.

The difference isn't all profit. It also has to cover the company's purchase and resale costs, its carrying costs during the work, its financing and the risk of repairs running over. Each company sets its own margins, so real offers can land above or below a rule like this.

No formula like this tells you what your house would bring as it stands on the open market. Recent sales of comparable houses in similar condition do, and that's the number for the listing column.

Not every cash buyer works the same way:

  1. Renovators buy, fix and resell the house themselves.
  2. Wholesalers put the house under contract and sell the contract to another investor for a fee. Watch for wording that lets the buyer "assign" the agreement.
  3. Instant-offer companies make an offer, inspect the house, and may then lower the price for repairs or take a service charge at closing. Compare the final figures, not the first offer.

The worksheet

A few rules make the comparison fair:

  • Use the same start date for both columns, such as today.
  • In the cash column, use the written offer. In the listing column, use a price supported by recent comparable sales, not the price you hope for.
  • Count each cost once. If the offer price already reflects a repair reduction, don't deduct the repairs again.
  • Leave a line blank until you have a real figure. Enter zero only when the item truly doesn't apply.

You can add a third column for listing the house as-is, with little or no preparation. Cash buyers can bid on a listed house too.

Line Cash offer Listing
1. Price: written offer, or supported expected sale price
2. Agent compensation: the total you agree to in writing
3. Company or service fees
4. Repair or condition deductions not already in line 1
5. Other credits or concessions to the buyer
6. Other closing charges: escrow, title, county transfer tax and similar
7. Clear-out, repairs and preparation
8. Carrying costs to closing, not counting the loan: property tax, insurance, utilities, HOA dues
9. Loan payoff on that closing date
10. Loan payments made before that closing
11. What's left: line 1 minus lines 2 through 10
Days from the start date to closing

Notes on the lines:

  • Line 2. Agent compensation is negotiable and set in writing. Enter the total the estate agrees to pay, including anything paid toward the buyer's agent, and count it only once.
  • Line 6. San Diego County's documentary transfer tax is $0.55 for every $500 of the price, which is $770 on a $700,000 sale. Your contract decides who pays which closing charges, and escrow can give you an estimate.
  • Lines 8 to 10. If there's a mortgage, ask the loan servicer for a payoff statement good through each possible closing date. A payoff includes interest up to that day and can include fees. Put the payments the estate makes before closing on line 10, and keep them out of line 8, so nothing is counted twice.
  • With a reverse mortgage there's usually no monthly payment, but the balance keeps growing, so a later closing means a higher payoff. Inherited Reverse Mortgage Home Sale covers the lender's timeline.

Line 11 isn't yet the heirs' share. The estate may still owe other debts and expenses, such as attorney and court costs, before anything is distributed, and income tax, if any, comes later.

It also won't match the check from escrow. The escrow statement covers only what's paid at closing, while the worksheet also counts money spent before closing, such as preparation and loan payments.

Two worked examples

Every figure below is invented to show how the worksheet works. None is a quote, a local average or a prediction. In both examples the house has a $200,000 mortgage, carrying costs other than the loan run $50 a day, and both columns start on the same day.

Example A: listing comes out ahead

A cash offer of $665,000 closes in 14 days. A listing expected to sell for $700,000 closes in 42 days.

Line Cash offer Listing
1. Price $665,000 $700,000
2. Agent compensation $0 −$22,000
3. Company or service fees −$4,000 $0
4. Condition deduction −$3,000 $0
5. Credits to the buyer $0 −$5,000
6. Other closing charges −$4,000 −$6,000
7. Clear-out and preparation −$1,000 −$5,000
8. Carrying costs at $50 a day −$700 −$2,100
9. Loan payoff at closing −$200,280 −$199,240
10. Loan payments before closing $0 −$1,600
11. What's left $452,020 $459,060
Days to closing 14 42

Listing leaves $7,040 more, for four more weeks and the work of preparing and showing the house. That margin is thin. With the same costs, a sale at $692,960 instead of $700,000 would leave the two paths even.

Example B: the cash offer comes out ahead

A cash offer of $690,000 closes in 14 days. A listing expected to sell for $700,000 closes in 70 days.

Line Cash offer Listing
1. Price $690,000 $700,000
2. Agent compensation $0 −$22,000
3. Company or service fees −$4,000 $0
4. Condition deduction −$3,000 $0
5. Credits to the buyer $0 −$5,000
6. Other closing charges −$4,000 −$6,000
7. Clear-out and preparation −$1,000 −$5,000
8. Carrying costs at $50 a day −$700 −$3,500
9. Loan payoff at closing −$200,280 −$198,200
10. Loan payments before closing $0 −$3,200
11. What's left $477,020 $457,100
Days to closing 14 70

Here the cash offer leaves $19,920 more and closes eight weeks sooner. With the same costs, the listing would have to sell for $719,920 just to match it. When a cash offer is close to a supported market price, the costs and time of listing can outweigh the difference.

Why the loan has two lines

In Example A, the estate makes $1,600 of loan payments before the listing closes. Part of that reduces the balance, which is why the listing's payoff is lower than the cash sale's. Counting both lines is correct, and the slower sale still pays $560 more in interest.

Two mistakes skew the result. Using today's full balance as the payoff and also subtracting the payments charges the same principal twice. Using the lower later payoff without the payments makes the slower sale look better than it is.

The break-even listing price

The break-even price is how high the listing has to sell just to match the cash offer:

Break-even price = the cash column's line 11 + the listing's lines 2 through 10

If agent compensation is a percentage of the price, leave it out of that sum and divide the result by one minus that percentage. Transfer tax and some escrow charges also move a little with the price.

Then ask whether a price supported by comparable sales clears the break-even by enough to be worth the extra time and work. With the costs unchanged, each $10,000 lower cash offer moves the result $10,000 in the listing's favor. In Example A, a $600,000 offer would leave listing $72,040 ahead.

What changes the result

Situation What changes on the worksheet
Repairs buyers will ask for, such as a roof, sewer line or termite damage Lines 5 and 7 can grow on the listing side. A cash company accounts for the same repairs, in its price or as a deduction. Get repair bids so both columns use real figures.
Serious safety or structural problems Standard loans generally require these to be fixed before closing, so more of the open-market buyers may be paying cash or using renovation loans, and the listing's line 1 may move closer to the cash offer.
A mortgage, reverse mortgage or high carrying costs Lines 8 to 10 grow with every extra week before closing. Use real payoff figures for each date.
A firm deadline, such as a loan due date, a foreclosure date or a tax sale The closing date may matter more than line 11. A certain, quick close can be worth more than the difference.
Heirs who agree only on a quick, final sale It isn't a line on the worksheet, but it's real. A smaller line 11 can be the right price for ending a dispute.

Getting Through the Buyer's Appraisal and Loan Conditions explains what lenders look for.

If the house is in probate or a trust

Three rules change the math for an estate:

  1. The 90% floor. When a probate sale needs court confirmation, the court can't confirm a private sale below 90% of the probate referee's appraisal. If the referee valued the house at $750,000, the lowest price the court could confirm would be $675,000, so a $665,000 cash offer couldn't be confirmed without a new appraisal. Probate Referee Value vs. Market Value explains the rule.
  2. Overbids. At a confirmation hearing, other buyers can bid more. The first overbid must be at least 10% more on the first $10,000 of the accepted price and 5% more on the rest. On a $665,000 accepted offer, the opening overbid would be at least $698,750.
  3. The duty to the heirs. An executor, administrator or trustee is selling for other people. A filled-in worksheet is a clear record of why the chosen sale made sense.

Check the terms behind the cash column

The cash column is only as good as the contract behind it. Before relying on it, check the proof of funds, any inspection or cancellation period, when the deposit becomes nonrefundable, whether the buyer can assign the contract, and any fee or credit taken at closing. Sell an Inherited House for Cash or List It? lists the questions to ask any cash buyer.

How I use this worksheet

When a family brings me a cash offer, I fill in both columns with them, using recent comparable sales for the listing price and the offer's actual terms for the cash side. Sometimes listing comes out well ahead. Sometimes the offer is the better fit for that house and that family, and the worksheet shows that too.

Questions heirs ask

Is "no fees, no commissions" a real saving?

You won't pay an agent. Whether that saves money depends on how far the offer sits below what the house would bring after the listing's costs, which is what line 11 measures.

Can we list an inherited house as-is?

Yes. Buyers using loans can buy an as-is house that meets the lender's standards, and cash buyers can bid on a listing too. Serious safety or structural problems generally have to be fixed before a standard loan closes.

Will a cash offer wait while we get ready to list?

Ask. Some offers expire quickly, and a buyer may or may not hold the same price later. Get any extension in writing.

How long does a listed sale take?

It depends on the preparation the house needs, how quickly the right buyer comes along, the buyer's financing and, in probate, the court's steps. Put your own estimate on the worksheet. The 42 and 70 days in the examples are only illustrations.

Does the worksheet include income tax?

No. An inherited share of a house generally takes a new tax basis equal to its value at the date of death, which can leave little taxable gain on a prompt sale. How much of the house that covers depends on how it was owned, so ask your CPA. Inherited San Diego Home Sale: Taxes, Basis and Capital Gains explains more.

Next step

If you have an offer in hand, send me the address and the offer through my cash-offer inquiry, call or text (619) 366-2000, or use the contact form.