Skip to content

San Diego Real Estate Guidance

Probate Referee Value vs. Market Value: What the Inventory Number Means for a San Diego House

Published · Updated

In a California probate, the house gets an official value early on. A probate referee, an appraiser appointed by the State Controller, values it as of the date of death, and that number goes into the estate's Inventory and Appraisal, which the court and every heir can read. Families naturally treat it as "what the house is worth." It's better understood as the court's starting number.

It comes up in three places: whether the court will confirm a sale price, the property tax reassessment (where the Assessor makes its own decision), and the income-tax basis of the inherited share. It doesn't set the list price. This guide explains what the referee does, why their number and the market drift apart, and how to work with the gap, including when to ask for a new appraisal.

Quick answers

  • The referee values the house and the estate's other non-cash assets as of the date of death. The executor or administrator values cash, bank accounts and similar items.
  • The Inventory and Appraisal is due within four months after letters are issued, though the court can allow more time.
  • In a sale that needs court confirmation, the price must be at least 90% of the appraised value, from an appraisal less than a year old at the hearing.
  • If the appraisal is stale, too high or too low, a new appraisal can be obtained before the sale, and the original referee can do it.
  • The date-of-death value is common evidence for the income-tax basis of the inherited share, a good reason to want it accurate.

What the probate referee does

California's Controller appoints probate referees in every county, and the court assigns one to each estate. The executor or administrator lists the estate's assets on the inventory and appraises the cash-like items: money, bank and money-market accounts, and insurance or retirement proceeds payable as lump sums. Then they deliver the inventory to the referee, with supporting data. The referee appraises everything else, including the house.

The referee is paid a commission of one-tenth of one percent of the value they appraise, with a $75 minimum and a $10,000 maximum per estate unless the court allows more, plus expenses. On a house appraised at $900,000, that's $900.

Why the referee's number and the market drift apart

The referee answers a narrow question: what was the property worth on the date of death? The market answers a different one: what will a buyer pay now, for this house, in its actual condition? Three ordinary things pull those apart:

Cause What happens Which way it pushes
Time Probate takes months, and the market moves Either way
Condition The referee may know little about the inside: the dated kitchen, the roof leak, the termite damage. A buyer's inspector finds all of it Usually makes the market lower than the appraisal on neglected houses
Comparables The appraisal leans on sales around the date of death. The sale happens later, against newer sales Either way

The "supporting data" that goes to the referee with the inventory is the family's chance to narrow the condition gap. Photos, inspection findings and repair bids tell the referee what can't be seen from the street.

That's why the list price should come from current market evidence: comparable sales, condition and today's buyers. The referee's value is a reference point and, in some sales, a floor. Pricing an Inherited San Diego Home: Executor Guide covers how to set the price.

The 90% rule for court-confirmed sales

When a probate sale needs court confirmation, which is the case when the executor or administrator has limited authority, Probate Code section 10309 sets conditions. The court won't confirm a private sale unless:

  • the accepted price is at least 90% of the appraised value, and
  • the house was appraised, with a valuation date, within one year before the confirmation hearing.
Referee's value Lowest price the court can confirm
$700,000 $630,000
$850,000 $765,000
$1,000,000 $900,000

When a new appraisal makes sense

Two situations call for one:

  1. The market is lower than the appraisal, because the house needs more work than the referee knew or prices have slipped. Offers come in under the 90% line, and none can be confirmed.
  2. The appraisal is more than a year old by the time of the hearing.

The law allows a new appraisal before the sale or its confirmation when the property was never appraised, when the appraisal or its valuation date is more than a year old, or when the court is satisfied the latest appraisal is too high or too low. The original referee can usually do it without a separate court order.

Bring the evidence: inspection reports, repair bids, current comparable sales and the offers you've received. Talk to the estate's attorney before you list if you expect this, so the new appraisal doesn't delay a good buyer.

When the estate has full authority

With full authority under the Independent Administration of Estates Act, a sale to an outside buyer usually closes without a confirmation hearing, after a Notice of Proposed Action goes to the heirs, normally at least 15 days ahead unless they consent in writing sooner.

Ask the estate's attorney how the appraisal applies to your sale. Practically, heirs read the inventory, so a price far below the referee's value needs a clear explanation, or it invites an objection that sends the sale to court anyway.

Property tax: a separate valuation

A death generally changes the ownership of whatever interest the person owned, which may be the whole house or only a share of it. Unless an exclusion applies, the San Diego County Assessor reassesses that interest to its value on the date of death, and supplemental tax bills follow for the difference. The Assessor decides the extent of the change and the value on its own, separately from the referee.

If you believe a supplemental assessment is too high, the appeal to the Assessment Appeals Board generally has to be filed within 60 days of the mailing date on the notice. Evidence that persuaded the referee, such as condition and repair bids, can help there too. Inherited a San Diego Home? Prop 19 and Your Property Tax explains when the parent-child exclusion avoids reassessment.

Income tax: the stepped-up basis

For income tax, an inherited share of a house generally takes a new basis equal to its fair market value at the date of death, or on a later alternate valuation date if the estate elects one. That can be higher or lower than what the owner paid. When the house sells soon after, the gain is measured from that value, which can leave little or none. The referee's appraisal is commonly used as evidence of it.

It isn't the only evidence, and it isn't binding. If the referee's number looks low, your CPA may want an independent date-of-death appraisal, since a low basis means more reported gain later. A later appraisal for the sale doesn't change the date-of-death value.

If the house was owned with someone else, how much of it takes a new basis depends on how it was owned, and community property has its own rules. That's a question for your CPA. Inherited San Diego Home Sale: Taxes, Basis and Capital Gains goes further.

How to work with the number

A practical order of operations:

  1. When the inventory comes back, compare the referee's value with a current market analysis.
  2. If the market is higher, list at market. The appraisal is never a ceiling, and it sets a floor only when the sale needs court confirmation.
  3. If the market is lower because of condition, gather the inspection findings and bids now. If the sale will need confirmation, discuss a new appraisal with the attorney before listing.
  4. Keep every comparable sale and repair bid in one file. The court, the heirs and the CPA may each ask for it.

When I price a probate house, I put my market analysis next to the referee's value and explain every difference: condition, time and comparables. That way the heirs, the attorney and, if it comes to it, the court are all reading the same reasoning.

If a cash buyer is offering well below the appraisal and the sale will need court confirmation, check that offer against the 90% floor before anything else. Cash Offer or Listing? A Net-Proceeds Worksheet shows the full comparison.

Questions heirs ask

Do we have to list the house at the referee's value?

No. The list price should come from the current market. The referee's value matters most as the 90% floor in a court-confirmed sale.

What if every offer is below 90% of the appraisal?

In a court-confirmed sale, ask the estate's attorney about a new appraisal and bring the evidence: inspection findings, repair bids, current comparable sales and the offers themselves. The law allows a new appraisal when the old one is stale, or when the court is satisfied it's too high or too low.

Can we give the referee information about the house?

Yes. The inventory goes to the referee with supporting data, and condition information, such as photos, inspection reports and repair bids, helps the referee value what they can't see.

Does the referee's value set our tax basis?

Not by itself. It's common evidence of the date-of-death value that sets the basis of the inherited share, but it isn't binding for tax purposes, and a later appraisal for the sale doesn't change it. Your CPA may recommend a separate date-of-death appraisal.

How long does the referee take?

The whole Inventory and Appraisal is due within four months after letters are issued, and the court can allow more time. Delivering the inventory and supporting data promptly keeps the referee's part moving.

Next step

Send me the address and the referee's value, and I'll show you how today's market compares and what that means for your price and the court's floor. Call or text (619) 366-2000, or use the contact form.